Warmup Inbox vs. Instantly: head-to-head
The products overlap on warmup and campaign sending, but the similarities start to thin out once you look at controls, pricing and the wider tools included with each subscription.
Warmup network
Both products use connected inboxes as part of their warmup networks. Instantly explicitly describes its Standard Pool as other Instantly users who have enabled warmup. Its Premium Pool uses aged Google and Microsoft accounts.
Warmup Inbox has more than 30,000 active inboxes in its network. On average, emails warmed through Warmup Inbox reach the Primary inbox 15% more often than with other warmup tools.
Winner: Warmup Inbox. Both use peer-to-peer warmup, but Warmup Inbox gives you its full warmup network without splitting access between Standard and Premium pools.
Warmup controls
Instantly lets you adjust daily volume, reply rate and several engagement signals.
Warmup Inbox lets you control starting volume, daily increases and maximum volume. Pro adds custom schedules and templates, specific ESP warmup and warmup in 12 languages.
Winner: Warmup Inbox. Both give you control over warmup activity, but Warmup Inbox adds more options for tailoring warmup to your sending setup and audience.
Price
Warmup Inbox starts at $15 per inbox per month annually. Instantly starts at $47 per month, with standard warmup included in the Outreach subscription.
At almost the same price as Instantly Growth, Warmup Inbox Pro adds the advanced warmup controls covered above. Instantly has the advantage when the number of connected inboxes is the main consideration, although Growth’s 5,000-email monthly allowance still limits campaign sending volume.
Winner: Warmup Inbox. It has the lower entry price and gives you a dedicated warmup option without requiring an Outreach subscription.
Campaign sending
Both Instantly and Warmup Inbox support cold email campaigns. Warmup Inbox offers multi-step sequences, contact imports, sending windows, daily limits, A/B testing and a unified inbox, with warmup continuing while campaigns run.
Instantly also supports campaign sending alongside its wider outreach and sales tools.
Winner: Tie. Both products give you the core tools to build, send and manage cold email campaigns.
Using warmup with another sequencer
Warmup Inbox connects directly to your mailbox, so you can use it alongside Instantly or another sending tool.
Instantly’s standard warmup requires a paid Instantly Outreach plan.
Winner: Warmup Inbox. You can add it to your existing setup without moving your outreach workflow into another product.